Self-Silencing social orders, especially the United States, lift up


Grounded in the
self-silencing model of female personality advancement (Chodorow, 1978;
Gilligan, 1982; Jack, 1987a; Jordan, Kaplan, Miller, Stiver, and Surrey, 1991;
Miller, 1976) and affected by communitarian inquire about with her tutor, Carol
Gilligan, analyzing females’ loss of self seeing someone, Jack (1987a, 1987b, 1991)
built up the self-silencing hypothesis of wretchedness in women. The
accompanying survey of the writing here will feature hypothetical suggestions,
ideas, and research correlated to the comprehension of self-silencing
hypothesis and its application to mental pain experienced by females. To start
with, self-silencing hypothesis will be investigated trailed by an outline of
research discoveries and conclusions put forward by Gilligan and her associates
(Brown and Gilligan, 1992; Gilligan, 1982; Gilligan et al., 1991). In
conclusion, ideas and research related particularly to self-hushing hypothesis
will be inspected. As opposed to different societies around the world that
observe a feeling of association as the sociocultural perfect, Western social
orders, especially the United States, lift up singular self-governance and
accomplishment as the sine qua non of passionate and social prosperity.
Subsequently, broadly acknowledged mental speculations of character and
identity improvement, including the Eriksonian model show (Erikson, 1968),
emerged from these esteemed Western esteems embracing rough independence.
Inside the Erikson model of character advancement, it is proposed that amid
youthfulness people must separate mentally from their folks and not depend upon
them to impact their own esteems with a specific end goal to accomplish a sound
feeling of self. Defenders of the self-inrelation demonstrate (Chodorow, 1978;
Gilligan, 1982; Jack, 1987a; Jordan et al., 1991; Miller, 1976) essentially
can’t help contradicting the utilization of this Eriksonian model to female 28
character advancement. Moreover, Gilligan et al. (1991) fought that the
propensity for pre-adult females to slander their own particular discernments
and convictions negates Erikson’s conceptualization that partition prompts a
more grounded feeling of self.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

Not at all like
Erikson’s model, the self-in-relation model does not see mental individuation
from one’s folks as a forerunner to solid personality arrangement in women.
Rather, the self-in-connection demonstrate places that female passionate
prosperity rises up out of the capacity to keep up commonly strong connections
in which there is real, proportional articulation of feelings and necessities
(Carr, Gilroy, and Sherman, 1996). That being stated, what occurs for youthful
females who live in a culture that undermines the significance of keeping up
mental connectedness to others as a way to build up a feeling of self, yet in
the meantime forces social weights to be the guardian of others? Thus lies the
formative conundrum confronting young ladies as they enter pre-adulthood.
Gilligan et al. (1991) suggested that repudiating the self, or what might as
well be called losing one’s voice, seeing someone is maybe an endeavor to
determine this formative emergency. Importance, by quieting one’s feelings and
considerations seeing someone young ladies are dodging struggle to look after
association, however in the meantime this concealment likewise serves to shield
the feeling of self from others’ feedback. In principle, the self and the
relationship are saved. Then again, a false social self develops which blocks
genuine closeness inside connections, denying youthful females the shared
credibility required for self-development and enthusiastic prosperity.
Expanding the investigation of ladies’ improvement to that of more youthful
females, Brown and Gilligan (1992) difficultly met more than 100 young ladies
for a long time amid the late 1980s to catch their encounters on the voyage
from adolescence to womanhood. This 29 broad work brought about meeting
transcripts loaded down with tales of disarray about and quieting of one’s feelings
and observations once achieving immaturity. Young ladies who had once talked so
aptly and transparently to others about their internal encounters started to
smother and uncertainty parts of themselves even with conceivable relationship
change. These analysts inferred that as females progress toward becoming
drenched in the social development of reality (i.e., social weights for females
to stifle negative feelings) they start to show a façade of consistence and
doubt their own particular experience of the world to educate their feelings,
considerations, and activities. Besides, this formative procedure, which
Gilligan alluded to as repudiation of the self, was guessed to add to
misconduct, high schooler pregnancy, and dietary problems in females.

To mention the
Self-Silencing Theory with reference to the research article of Self-silencing
as a mediator and moderator of adult attachment and disordered eating attitudes
by Shannon Kellim Young was of the reason that Self Silencing gives poor
correlation with all the variables due to many concerns. The present study
expands this line of research by exploring possible mediators and moderators of
this association cited in extant researchs. Specifically, this study examined
whether self-silencing serves as a mediator and moderator between Gratitude and
relationship of working and non-working women. The most significant findings
were self-silencing partially mediated the relation between gratitude and
relationships of working and non-working women. Whereas, self-silencing is way
less in working women as compared to non-working women.

There could be
many possible reason of this weak correlation some of the important one
according to the eastern culture of Pakistan are here follows:

of the Pakistani culture are used to praise and their spouse as assistant to
God on earth. Which directly project to their tendency of not raising their
voices against any issue involving violence and other matters.

of social desirability in women are higher then men. Thus, we can possibly
assume that women didn’t likely to reveal their internal problems by showing
high scores on self-silencing. (James R. Hebert et. Al 1997)

of working Class are more prone to raise their voices which ultimately predicts
low level of gratitude in them. (Table 4)

Style with their Spouse can also be the hidden factor behind low correlation in
the results. For example, there is a possibility that as most of the married
couples in this culture are most likely to be in relationship pf arrange
marriage which insist them to remain quiet for their own better good.

Coming to the
issue of Social Desireability it is possibly assumed that, women in the
Pakistani culture are less likely to show openness to their experiences when it
is about their marital life either it is about working class or non-working
class. (see Table 2)

Under these circumstances,
we can assume that women from any sort of occupation either house wives or
working women, they tend to show self silencing even when it is about being
open to how they feel to remain silent. Or even if it has no effect on their
marital life i.e no utterance on Gratitude and no positive effect on

Moreover, there
are two possible interpretations for the present results. First, women with
high attachment anxiety tend to have a negative internal working model of self
(Pietromonaco & Barrett, 2000). They not only devalue their own needs and
emotions but also pay more attention to meet external standards in order to
please others and maintain relationship and self-worth. Because their
self-worth is built on external standards and sources of validation their
vulnerability to unrealistic societal standards of body size and beauty is
increased, which may then contribute to disordered eating attitudes. Likewise,
women with high attachment avoidance tend to hold a negative working model of
others (Pietromonaco & Barrett). Thus, they might have limited capacities
for trusting others and anticipate others will disappoint them. As such, they may
be less likely to engage in emotional self-disclosure to others and may
defensively deny relational needs, presenting a façade of independence through
excessive self-reliance. However, these defensive strategies may engender the
added risks of disordered eating (e.g., emotion-based eating and/or rigid
control of food consumption) to suppress their feelings.

That is,
previous literature has suggested that those with attachment anxiety and
attachment avoidance may engage in behaviours to avoid hurt or rejection in
relationships by relationship preoccupation and relationship distance,
respectively. However, the underlying motivations may differ depending on the
degree of avoidance and anxiety experienced (Fraley & Shaver, 2000).
Specifically, those with high attachment anxiety are more likely to sustain
close emotional connections with others by placing others needs over their own
needs but silencing their frustration and anger. However, those with high
attachment avoidance are more likely to diminish true intimacy and dependence
on others by restricting their expression of needs or emotions to prevent
interpersonal hurt. Empirically, the results of this study are consistent with
past research suggesting that those with attachment anxiety are likely to
demonstrate self-silencing within relationships (Remen et al., 2002).

It is possible
that specific components of self-silencing are differentially associated with
certain categories of relationships which might not be discussed or assumed

For example,
scores on Gratitude may be weakly positively associated with the scores on the
SS Scale Divided Self-Subscale subscale as this subscale measures the tendency
to conceal one’s true self in relationships. Moreover, considering
self-silencing serves as a mediator between gratitude and occupation, future
research designed to assess the treatment efficacy of interventions helping
women develop alternative ways to express their feelings and needs in
relationships is strongly supported.

In conclusion,
the present study empirically examined self-silencing as a predictor of Gratitude
and in women of working and non-working class. The results suggest that
self-silencing not act as a very good predictor of gratitude but this idea can
be merged as there is a strong impact of Social desirability and cultural
differences in Pakistan. These results contribute to the limited empirical data
on the implications of the Self Silencing theory to adult female populations
demonstrating low level of gratitude due to self silencing in both the cases whether
it is working or non-working class. Finally, this study suggests that mental
health professionals may be able to help women with level of confidence to
avoid self-silencing when it has no impact on gratitude and  avoidance by validating and encouraging
emotional expression within relationships as a means to decrease their levels
of guilt for being silent or not living a happy life.